QualityDipStocks / Finance · Property-Casualty Insurers
Selective Insurance Group SIGI
Outside our quality screen, so we don’t track its dips. It’s 1% below its 52-week high.
Outside our quality screen, trading above our fair value estimate.
- Fair value est.
- $86.04−13%
- Market Value
- $97.87price +1%
- Off 52-wk high
- −1%
- Risk vs market
- Lowbeta −0.13
3 bullish · 4 bearish See why
Key levels
Every level vs today’s $98.83
- 52-wk lowlowest close, 1 year$73.72−25.4%
- Fair value est.base case$86.04−12.9%
- Market Valueavg paid since Oct 22$97.87−1.0%
- PriceFri Oct 30 close$98.83you are here
- 52-wk highhighest close, 1 year$100.15+1.3%
Fair value estimate
How the range is computed
Financials model (residual income). Same residual-income model as the base: cost of equity 9.5% ±1 point and return on equity 12.5% ±2 points. Bear = 10.5% and 10.5%; bull = 8.5% and 14.5%. A model estimate from public filings, not a forecast of where the price will go.
Price sits inside the range.
What the price implies To be worth today’s price, SIGI would need a return on equity of about 14% a year; our estimate uses 12%.
Risk vs market
How risk vs market is measured
One year of daily returns (Oct 30 to Oct 30, 252 sessions). Beta = how much SIGI moved for each 1% move in the S&P 500 (SPY); 1.0 moves with the market. Volatility is the yearly standard deviation of daily returns. Past behavior, not a forecast.
Has moved mostly independently of the market, but its own price swings are 1.8× the S&P 500’s (it moves on its own news).
- Beta vs S&P 500
- -0.13
- Volatility
- 24% vs 13% SPY
- Correlation SPY
- −0.07
- Correlation QQQ
- −0.19
Bull vs bear
Rule-based from the data on this page, strongest first. Not advice.
Top bullish points 3 of 5
GrowthDiluted EPS grew 132% to $7.49 in FY2025.
GrowthSales compounded 14% a year from FY2022 to FY2025.
ValuationP/E of 11.6×, below the 13.5× median for the 151 Finance companies we cover.
Top bearish points 4 of 5
ValuationOur residual-income fair value estimate is $86.04, 13% below the price.
GrowthSales growth slowed to 4% over the last 12 months, from 14% a year over the prior three fiscal years.
ProfitabilityNet margin of 9.2%, below the 21% median for the 142 Finance companies we cover.
QualityDoesn’t pass our quality screen: sales down vs the year-ago quarter.
Who’s talking about it
Notable investors, executives, analysts and public figures on Selective Insurance Group in the last 48 hours. Headlines as published, each linked. Their words, not ours.
No notable mentions in the last 48 hours. Checked Nov 1, 9:09 PM ET.
Compare with peers
Closest in size in Property-Casualty Insurers
All fundamentals
P/E 11.6 · ROE 14% · Sales +4%
Valuation
- P/E
- 11.6×Finance median 13.5×
- Price / FCF
- n/acash flow isn't a clean measure for an insurer
- FCF yield
- n/acash flow isn't a clean measure for an insurer
- EV / EBITDA
- n/anot meaningful for an insurer
- Price / sales
- 1.07×
- Price / book
- 1.69×
- Market cap
- $5.8Bprice × diluted shares
- Enterprise value
- n/anot reported in its SEC filings
Growth
- Revenue, 12 months
- $5.4B
- Sales growth, 12 months
- +4.0%vs the 12 months before
- Sales growth, 3 yrs
- +14.5%/yrfrom FY2022
- Diluted EPS, 12 months
- $8.32
- EPS growth, last FY
- +131.9%
- Net income, 12 months
- $502M
- Net income growth
- +26%12 months vs before
Profitability
- Gross margin
- n/anot meaningful for an insurer
- Operating margin
- n/anot reported in its SEC filings
- Net margin
- 9.2%
- FCF margin
- 20.9%
- Return on equity
- 14%
- Return on invested capital
- n/anot meaningful for an insurer
Balance sheet
- Cash & short-term inv.
- $15M
- Total debt
- n/anot reported in its SEC filings
- Net cash
- n/anot meaningful for an insurer
- Debt / equity
- n/adeposits/float make debt/equity not comparable for an insurer
- Interest coverage
- n/anot meaningful for an insurer
Cash flow & returns
- Free cash flow, 12 months
- $1.1B
- FCF growth, 12 months
- −1%
- Dividend yield
- 1.71%$100M paid
- Payout ratio
- 20%
- Buybacks, 12 months
- $153M2.6% of market cap
- Share count, 1 year
- −1.9%diluted shares vs a year ago
- Stock-based comp
- $24M
Trailing 12 months to Sep 30, 2026; balance sheet at Sep 30, 2026. From Selective Insurance Group’s SEC filings. Sparklines show up to six fiscal years. n/a means we don’t hold that number, with the reason. How each is computed.
Valuation details
DCF $86.04 · MV $97.87
Financials model (residual income): book value $63.35 a share on Sep 30, 2026 (preferred stock excluded), plus the earnings above a 9.5% cost of equity. ROE 12.5%, the average of 13.9% for the trailing 12 months to Sep 30, 2026 and 11.0% over fiscal 2021–2025, on average common equity; payout 46% of earnings (dividends 20% + net buybacks 26%), so book grows by the retained rest; the return above 9.5% fades halfway toward 9.5% over 10 years, then grows at 3% (terminal value). From the 10-Q filed Oct 23, 2026.
Setup & signals
No setup armed
No setup armed, so there’s no trigger or stop to track yet. Reversal signal rules only run on companies that pass our quality screen.
Momentum & 52-week range
RSI 75 · 5 days +2.3%
The business
Sales −2%
- Return on equity15%
- Sales growth (latest quarter vs year-ago quarter)−2%
Information only, not investment advice. Fair value estimates and talking points are rule-based model output from public data and can be wrong; stop levels are reference points, not orders. How every number is computed.
SIGI is outside our quality screen
One text when a published rule fires on one of the 333 quality companies we track: the ticker, the price, the stop and a link to the numbers. Nothing else.